There’s something about the salty ocean air that makes sweet treats taste even better. If you’re strolling the charming streets of Fernandina Beach with a sugar craving, you’re in luck! This historic beach town on Amelia Island is home to some seriously delicious locally owned bakeries and dessert shops. Whether you’re a visitor looking to treat yourself or a local on the hunt for your next sugar fix, I’ve rounded up the absolute best places to satisfy your sweet tooth in Fernandina Beach.
Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop – 13 N 3rd St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
Tucked away on North 3rd Street, Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop feels like walking into your grandmother’s kitchen – if your grandmother happened to be an exceptionally talented pastry chef. The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by the intoxicating scent of butter, sugar, and freshly baked goods.
Their key lime pie is legendary among locals, with the perfect balance of tart and sweet. But don’t overlook their signature cinnamon rolls, which are pillowy soft with a gooey center and just the right amount of frosting. If you’re planning a special occasion, their custom cakes are not only beautiful but absolutely delicious. Pro tip: arrive early, as their popular items sell out fast, especially on weekends!
Fernandina’s Fantastic Fudge – 218 Centre St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
A staple of Centre Street since 1988, Fernandina’s Fantastic Fudge lives up to its name. Walking by the shop is dangerous – the sweet aroma wafting out the door is nearly impossible to resist. Inside, you can watch as skilled confectioners fold and pull creamy fudge on marble slabs, a mesmerizing process that’s entertainment in itself.
While their classic chocolate fudge is divine, adventurous eaters should try unique flavors like amaretto chocolate swirl, or peanut butter chocolate. Beyond fudge, they also make exceptional hand-dipped chocolates, caramel apples, and pralines. During summer, their hand-scooped ice cream provides the perfect cool-down after a day at the beach.
Amelia Island Coffee – 207 Centre St. Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
More than just your average coffee shop, Amelia Island Coffee serves up some seriously delicious pastries alongside their expertly brewed beverages. Located in the heart of downtown, it’s the perfect spot to fuel up before exploring Fernandina Beach.
Their display case is always stocked with an array of tempting treats, from flaky croissants to gooey cinnamon buns. The cream cheese danish is particularly sublime – buttery pastry topped with sweetened cream cheese and seasonal fruits. Pair it with their signature Amelia Island blend coffee for a perfect coffee date pick me up. The cozy atmosphere makes it tempting to linger, especially if you snag one of the comfortable window seats perfect for people-watching.
Island Time Frozen Yogurt – 306 Centre St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
When the Florida heat kicks in, Island Time Frozen Yogurt offers the perfect cool treat. This self-serve frozen yogurt shop lets you be the master of your dessert destiny, with a rotating selection of flavors and an impressive toppings bar.
The beauty of Island Time is the freedom to create exactly what you want – whether that’s a virtuous cup of tart original topped with fresh berries or a decadent mountain of chocolate yogurt buried under candy pieces, hot fudge, and whipped cream. They regularly feature seasonal flavors like pumpkin pie in fall or peppermint stick during the holidays. The bright, cheerful atmosphere makes it a favorite for families, and the outdoor seating area is perfect for enjoying your creation while soaking up some sunshine.
Vintage Donuts – 503A Centre St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
For donut enthusiasts, Vintage Donuts is nothing short of paradise. This retro-inspired shop specializes in made-to-order cake donuts that come out hot, fresh, and utterly irresistible.
What makes Vintage unique is their process—you can watch as your donuts are prepared from start to finish. Choose your coating (think cinnamon sugar, chocolate glaze, or vanilla frosting), then add toppings like rainbow sprinkles, crushed Oreos, or bacon pieces. The result is a warm, fluffy donut with a slightly crisp exterior that simply melts in your mouth. Their donut holes are equally delicious and perfect for sharing (though you might not want to).
The Cinnamon Bear Country Store – 107 Centre St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
Don’t let the name fool you – The Cinnamon Bear Country Store is much more than just a store. This family-owned gem offers an impressive selection of candies, from nostalgic classics to gourmet treats you won’t find elsewhere on the island.
Their homemade fudge rivals any on the island, with unique flavors like tiger butter and cappuccino. The shop also stocks a delightful array of old-fashioned candy, hand-dipped chocolates, and salt water taffy. What makes The Cinnamon Bear special is the warm, welcoming atmosphere; the owners are always happy to offer samples or share stories about the history of the store and Fernandina Beach itself.
Whether you’re craving a fresh-baked pastry, creamy fudge, artisanal coffee and treats, cool frozen yogurt, hot donuts, or classic candy, Fernandina Beach has something to satisfy every sweet tooth. The best part? Each of these spots is locally owned and operated, meaning your indulgence supports the wonderful community that makes this beach town so special. So go ahead, treat yourself!
13 Bakery – 121 S 9th St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
North Florida’s first dedicated gluten-free bakery, is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious, gluten-free indulgences. After being diagnosed with Celiac Disease, owner Tina set out to create desserts that didn’t compromise on taste or texture. What began as a home-based bakery grew into a charming storefront in a historic home, offering cheesecakes, cupcakes, custom wedding cakes, and French macarons. The bakery also hosts decorating classes for kids and adults, making it a sweet spot for both treats and creativity.
